Free, confidential case reviews

Mesothelioma GuideResearch & Compensation
Organized binder of work and medical records

Legal

Personal Injury vs Wrongful Death

A living patient files a personal injury claim; after death the estate files wrongful death

Topic
Legal claims & lawsuits
Reading time
3 min
Understand the diagnosis

The type of claim depends on whether the person with mesothelioma is living. A living patient brings a personal injury claim in their own name. After a death, the claim usually shifts to a wrongful death action, and sometimes a survival action, brought through the estate. The two types differ in who files, what can be recovered and which deadlines apply.

Claims filed by a living patient

In a personal injury claim, the person diagnosed is the plaintiff. They can describe their own work history and symptoms, which is often the strongest evidence a case can have. Damages may include medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and in some cases a spouse's related losses. Because the patient's testimony is so valuable, attorneys often arrange to record it early. If the patient later passes away, the case doesn't simply end. It is usually converted so the estate and family can continue it, though some details change along the way.

Claims filed after a death

A wrongful death claim is brought on behalf of family members who lost a loved one. State law decides who may file, often through a personal representative of the estate. Damages typically focus on the family's losses, such as lost financial support, funeral costs and loss of companionship. Many states also allow a survival action, which carries forward the claims the person could have brought while alive. Without the patient's own testimony, these cases often rely more on coworkers, family members and records to show where exposure happened and which products were involved.

Why the difference affects timing

Personal injury and wrongful death claims usually run on separate clocks. A personal injury deadline often starts at diagnosis, while a wrongful death deadline usually starts at the date of death. If a patient dies before filing, the family may need to act quickly to preserve both types of claims where the state allows it. An estate may need to be opened before a wrongful death claim can be filed, which takes time. Understanding which claim applies, and when each clock started, helps families avoid losing options during an already difficult period.

What to do next

  1. 1

    Determine whether the claim will be brought by a living patient or by an estate.

  2. 2

    If a loved one has died, ask the probate court how to open an estate in their home county.

  3. 3

    Gather the diagnosis date and, if applicable, the date of death on official records.

  4. 4

    Ask a case reviewer which claim types your state allows and when each deadline began.

Questions

Common questions

Find out in minutes whether a claim is still available

Free, confidential case review for patients and families in all 50 states.

Powered by IRPR(opens in a new tab)